Video to submit? https://forms.gle/HmwnDQKvwvYPxe967
Blog: https://thecivilrightslawyer.com/
Donate to the Institute for Justice: https://ij.org/support/give-now/thecivilrightslawyer/
For business inquiries: civilrightslawyer@ellify.com
Twitter: https://twitter.com/johnbryanesq
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/JohnBryanLaw
Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@thecivilrightslawyer
FAIR USE NOTICE This video may contain copyrighted material; the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available for the purposes of criticism, comment, review and news reporting which constitute the fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. Notwithstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work for purposes such as criticism, comment, review and news reporting is not an infringement of copyright.
NOTE: We don’t condone threats or violence of any kind. If you are upset or outraged by acts of government misconduct featured in this video, we encourage you to utilize lawful means of expression, including becoming involved in the political process, as well as seeking accountability through the judicial system.
NOTE ALSO: The information you obtain here is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. We invite you to contact us and welcome your letters and electronic mail, or other submissions or messages. However, contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send any confidential information to us until such time as an attorney-client relationship is established and documented in a written agreement.
source
If the cops arrest the wrong person on a valid arrest warrant for someone else with the same name, does that violate the Fourth Amendment? Well, it depends…
Just a mistake the cop is a nice man so give the man a couple of bucks for his trouble and let’s move on.
Learn to read a id
this happens in oklahoma regularly. tulsa oklahoma specifically. you can even see it on their jail booking site, wrong person arrested.
Human trafficing.
I try to take ownership right away so that I can put more than enough effort into correcting the behavior or fixing the mistake. We're human, we make mistakes, but when you deflect, makes you wonder if it was intentional.
I'm not surprised that an officer of the laws is lacking a little integrity. This is expected behavior, by design.
They threw his lucky rock on the ground.
Shouldn't have given ID
Sue Sue Sue Sue Sue for millions millions millions millions millions millions
I would argue that Johnson V. Miller 1982 is a distinctly different set of facts than this video presents: The bank took out a criminal complaint against Johnson, giving her name and address. Johnson was the named suspect. The fact that the bank was confused is not technically the cops fault according to our Justice System (Where you can be actually innocent and be denied release, as long as all of the proper procedures are followed throughout the district court and appellate court and so on). They failed to withdraw the criminal complaint against Johnson despite being notified after her first arrest. This is a completely different set of facts. Also, presumably the record has advanced since 1982. It would be an interesting case to try at the 7th Circuit.
Ok I find a couple of things wrong here.
1). Cop got called for what, loading up stuff from a storage bldg. The guy showed the paper for storage. This should have ended the encounter.
2). After the encounter the deputy, got everyone's I.D. for no crime. I feel that's a 4th ammendment violation. Illegal detention false imprisonment. Kiddnapping.
Putting him in cuffs is cruel and unusual punishment.. cuffs are torture, so 8, th ammendment violation. After verification of being wrong. No warrant for the guy they arrested. So maybe 14th ammendment violation. Dispatch verified the correct information. But the deputy didn't confirm the information. Date of birth, digits for SSN. I think this is a complete abuse of power. Also Putting the in cuffs excessive use of force
His dob on his i.d. that's bs😂
Lawsuit
At least the cop took him back. I got hauled in on a bogus charge and got it dropped shortly after getting to the magistrate office. I was then told I was free to go. I told the officers that they brought me there on bogus charges. They said I was released and getting back to my vehicle wasn't their problem. The only fortunate thing I encountered was they didn't call to get my vehicle towed.
Just like any job you can not just pluck any guy off the street sprinkle pixie dust over them and say go do it, just like you can't just spinkle pixie on just anyone to make a doctor, a machinist, a mechanic, a lawyer. What could go wrong? Then you through in now lets don't hold them accountable for their actions……. what could go wrong?
No harm no foul! Right?! He was wrong & lied. But the man who was arrested wasn't bothered much. It's all our in the open now so maybe if there's any thing that needs fixing ie: better training or something, then possibly the captain over there will see 2 it.
Realistically it’s both of their faults but then blaming his dispatch for the whole thing is wrong, he didn’t have to take him anywhere if he looked at his date of birth right from the start he’s a crooked cop just like most of them and failing to be honest proves that only my opinion.
If the citizen would have thrown a fit and resisted arrest, he'd have a better case to sue, lol
Not an honest mistake its negligence
More stupid cops? Cant they check date of birth and address? They can barely read
Dumbo 's
LEO's are congenital compulsive liars.
This cop straight up lying to the end, typical tyrant behavior.
Question, Were they even required to provide ID to the officer¿
It could certainly gone worse. He had ample sources to confirm the identity in today's technology. I agree it would be an uphill battle, especially with cordiality.
Complete CYA but the guy took it well
I'm going to give the police this one . People use different DOB , Names ,etc .Be thankful this cop corrected his and dispatch mistake . You know there are cops out there that would have said screw it ,let the jail and judge figure it out .
so let me get this straight, they just have a name and birthday for a warrant? No photo? No last known description? No ID image? So other than hearing a name, hearing a confirmed (with missing the wrong info) there is nothing to say "this is your person". What is to stop an officer from randomly picking someone up that they claim is X name that matches X name on Z warrant?
“It’s more on us, than it is on you.”
No… it’s not on him at all.
I would have insisted on riding in the front seat on the way back. SUE. SUE SUE.
The cop did everything perfectly, according to the cops, they just arrested the wrong person.
Here's a surprise… cops that are too stupid to be able to arrest the right person… Another shocking occurrence – the pig lies. WOAH… Those things never happen.
Any agency trying warrants against a national, or international, database can't identify based on just a name. They have access to other details such as DOB, SS#, & DL#. Only a totally incompetent fool could arrest the guy without confirming a single valid detail. Many people have the same name.
This is really hard to believe as real. Police aren't that incompetent. This would be sub 70 IQ.
Is it mandatory that cops got to be stupid as hell?
Lying Cop didn’t check ID when given the correct info over radio. Scum bag deflected blame to Dispatcher.
Cops lie? Say it ain’t so.
This is a case of " The Overzealous cop! and yes, it's on you, the cop who didn't actually look at the driver license or listen to the false arrest victim who clearly stated his D.OB
Freedom is an illusion and tyrants are scary.
Yes
I don't think he did anything wrong. But the only way to really know is to hear him call in the names. If he gave the dispatcher there DOB then she should not have. Know what the more I think of this. It's all on the dispatcher. I'm just being real. I'm a convicted felon who hates the police. But go after the bad ones. Not saying he is a good one. But from this video I would be comfortable being stopped by him opposed to some
That's what cop's do . "LIE"
This so called mistake is in fact a serious failure to check personal details by the police officer. The fellow who was detained, deserves a full apology and compensation for being handcuffed and taken to the police station.
that criminal blue coder just littered he is under citizen arrest plus drug test—–>no bond by: order of me a possible jury member the real law enforcer
Cop made a mistake. Probably didn't hear dispatch. I can see this being an honest one. But blameing the dispatch is a problem. But he probably believes it. Chalk it up to bad day.
Why surrender an ID when it still does no good against false identification or arrest? This is completely the fault of the officer, and there should be accountability for it on his part.
Cant make this stuff up
The cop should go to jail the dispatcher should be fired and charged. I can be sued and jailed at my shop if I mess up a vehicle because I didn't double check my work. DOUBLE CHECK YOUR WORK!
They even lie to themselves and to each other lol crazy ppl then expect them to tell the truth about u when they try to convict u and charge u with fines and BS
The police have to be held to higher standards. He made a mistake and his inability to take responsibility means he's not trustworthy. His word is not good because not only did he not take responsibility he then lied. Big red flags!
So besides the blame game of who was wrong, the guy still was arrested. But what i have noticed on many videos is police type on their laptops, text on phones, talk on phones while driving, see it in video of chases, and routine. Does police have some sort of immunity us mere mortals don't have? Given all the money spent on psa' etc, why?
Now Officer Stupid, is using a phone whilst driving, thus endangering his captive passanger. I doubt the supervisor investigated this incident at all. Then he lies again, saying the date of birth WAS the same and now it's just the SSA# being off "just a couple digits". The court set the bar low, because they know how stupid the average cop is.